Critical Reflection Outline
Project Title: Job Interview (Comedy Short Film)
Word Count Target: 1000 words
Purpose: To evaluate how the media product was developed and how it engages with genre conventions, audience, branding, and representation.
I. Introduction
Brief overview of the film concept
Main theme: discomfort in unfamiliar environments presented through comedy
Establish intent of the reflection
II. Research and Use/Challenge of Conventions
A. Research Process: studied core elements of comedy genre (exaggeration, awkwardness, etc.)
B. Sample Productions Analyzed:
- The 40-Year-Old Virgin
- Character-driven humor
- Awkward, exaggerated dialogue
- Natural feel through improvisation
- American Pie
- Physical comedy, teen humor
- Situational awkwardness
- Building tension
- Are We Doing This? (short film)
- Miscommunication and escalation
- Reactions drive humor
- Toothpick Intervention for Donny (Dress Up Gang)
- Absurd humor over trivial problems
- Intense treatment of small issues
- C. Techniques Applied in Own Film
- Dialogue timing and awkward escalation
- Use of relatable yet exaggerated scenarios
- Focused on character reactions
- Confusing interview setting
III. Audience Engagement
A. Target Audience Description
Ages 18–27
Interest in comedy and short-form entertainment
All genders
B. Engagement Through Social Media
Created a campaign to promote humor and relatability
Posts include memes, behind-the-scenes content, and sneak peeks
C. Engagement Through Postcard
Designed for indie film festival setting
Clean,Visuals paired with comedic taglines
Appeals to festival goers and niche comedy fans
D. Engagement Through the Film
Short plot
Humor rooted in awkward social interactions
Dialogue made to surprise audience
IV. Cohesion Across Products
A. Brand Identity
Lighthearted, awkward humor
Situational comedy with some exaggerated characters
Minimalist visuals with comedic tone
B. Alignment Across Products
Film, postcard, and social media consistently use humor or comical elements
All products lean into awkwardness and exaggeration
Social media tone reflects humor found in the short film
V. Representation of Social Groups/Issues
A. Representation Overview
Characters represent young adults navigating adult spaces
No specific identity-based social issues addressed
Focus is on universal experience of discomfort and confusion in unfamiliar environments
B. Effectiveness of Representation
Representation is broad and intentionally non-specific
Goal is relatability rather than commentary
Reflects feelings of disorientation many face post-college or in early careers
VI. Brief Conclusion
Now it is time to write this bad boy😎